Since we recommended Anne Fisher’s Ask Annie Column in this space earlier this year, I feel obligated to urge you to ignore her latest column, “What’s Your Greatest Weakness?”
While most interviewing advice that gets published is rubbish, this is particularly bad rubbish, because so many folks want to know the secret to this question. It’s not hard…
but it is not what is recommended in the article. For instance:
“Next time you’re stumped…try steering the conversation toward another topic.”
Rubbish. Interviewers do NOT like this tactic. Try it twice and we will politely end an interview. When we ask a question, we expect an answer to OUR question, not the answer YOU want to give us. No offense, but this is just lame.
Further:
“Instead of hashing over a current weakness (assuming you can think of one)…”
First, let me clue you in on something: you have weaknesses. The idea that you can’t “think of one” ought to embarrass the hell out of you. Either you are so nervous you can’t think (this is bad in an interview), or you haven’t done even the most basic of preparation (this is also bad in an interview).
“…talk about a past shortcoming and how you resolved it.”
Why would we care about this when we asked about a weakness in the present tense? You might as well say, “when I was 9 months old, I had trouble walking, but through steady effort I overcame this shortcoming, and, as you probably noticed earlier, I’m quite adept at the skill today.”
“The idea is that you are interested in getting better…”
Uh, NO. That’s not the idea. The idea is for you to tell us a weakness, to see if you’ve thought about your abilities relative to this job, and have prepared.
“Talk about how the job you’re applying for will help you stretch and build your skills.”
Um, NO. We know that already, thank you.
“Describe a valuable piece of advice someone gave you…”
Have I made my point?
Lucky for you, you won’t make any of these rookie mistakes… which is a competitive advantage right now, because thousands of people WILL after reading this article.
(And judging by the comments posted on Annie’s blog, there are a LOT of bad answers ready to be delivered right now.)
Anybody interested in a cast on how to answer this question?